This Sinclair Comparator is an excellent tool to use to sort bullets by base to give length. This is a valuable step if you are considering trimming the bullet meplat. NOTE: When sorting a lot of bullets, a digital caliper is sometimes a better choice for some handloaders than a dial caliper. An alternative tool to use for sorting bullets is our Sinclair Bullet Sorting Stand (#59-2000) which uses its own unique comparators. Our Sinclair Bullet Comparator attaches to the blade of your caliper and uses inserts for each specific caliber. The inserts are stainless steel and machined with a taper and a short straight section to more accurately duplicate the chamber throat. This eliminates the wobble experienced with many comparators which have standard drilled holes. Our design allows you to quickly and accurately measure the bullet's bearing surface of the bullet. Comparator inserts are available in 17 thru 45 caliber, and they can be used in both the Sinclair and older Stoney Point comparator bodies. These inserts are not intended to measure rounds seated to magazine length or shorter. For this application please see our Sinclair Bullet Comparators (#09-600 and #09-700).
Plus...
Ce comparateur Sinclair est un excellent outil pour trier les balles par longueur de base. C'est une étape précieuse si tu envisages de couper le méplat de la balle. REMARQUE : Lors du tri d'un grand nombre de balles, un pied à coulisse numérique est parfois un meilleur choix pour certains chargeurs que le pied à coulisse à cadran. Un outil alternatif pour trier les balles est notre support de tri de balles Sinclair (#59-2000) qui utilise ses propres comparateurs uniques. Notre comparateur de balles Sinclair se fixe à la lame de ton pied à coulisse et utilise des inserts pour chaque calibre spécifique. Les inserts sont en acier inoxydable et usinés avec un cône et une courte section droite pour reproduire plus précisément la gorge de la chambre. Cela élimine le balancement rencontré avec de nombreux comparateurs qui ont des trous standard percés. Notre conception te permet de mesurer rapidement et avec précision la surface de contact de la balle. Les inserts de comparateur sont disponibles pour les calibres de 17 à 45, et ils peuvent être utilisés à la fois dans les corps de comparateur Sinclair et les anciens corps de Stoney Point. Ces inserts ne sont pas destinés à mesurer des cartouches chargées à la longueur de magazine ou plus courtes. Pour cette application, merci de consulter nos comparateurs de balles Sinclair (#09-600 et #09-700).
Plus...
Évaluations client de SINCLAIR INTERNATIONAL XL BULLET COMPARATOR & BUMP GAGE BODY
Nombre d'évaluations: 13
De brownells.com: 13
Note moyenne: 3.1
Great little tool(13.12.2013)
I bought this comparator to use with the Sinclair XL Comparator body. It fits like a glove and gives accurate measurements from the ojive of the bullet to the base. Buy two of them and two bodies and you can also measure bearing surface of the bullet. I would definitely buy it again.
Well built, but not accurate(20.01.2015)
I have the Hornady bullet comparator that I normally use. When my shooting partner and I noticed a .010 difference in our Hornady headspace comparator, I ordered the Sinclair bump gauge and the bullet comparator. The Sinclair tool is produced from quality steel and is well constructed.
My issue with the tool is that on Sierra MK and Berger Juggernauts, it slides all the way down almost to the base of the bullet. I can't get repeatable results with this tool, where I can with the Hornady tool which is only made of light aluminum. The Sinclair tool does not seem to be measuring from the ogive, but more from the bullet base. As another user reviewed, when used with Comparator body, it measure 1.1 inches, rather than 1.0 like the Hornady. Because of the inaccuracy and non-repeatable readings on the same bullet, I can't continue using this.
Well built and accurate(18.07.2016)
I reviewed this item back in Jan 2015. However, I had just read that the manufacturer had some quality control issues back then, but these have been corrected, so I decided to give these another try. These new ones are much better than before, and hold the bullet securely at the ogive, or the pressure ring on the base by the boat tail. I ordered 2 to get readings on the bearing surface for different bullets, and I get accurate, repeatable readings every time. I have them in the Sinclair body. Since they are cut with a chambering reamer, the bullet fits securely in the insert. In my Hornady insert, the bullet will "wobble" since the insert is cut straight, and you have to make sure it goes on straight on the caliper. This inserts are made of high quality material, and are a must for competitive long range shooters.
Improved design for comparator inserts.(07.12.2010)
Measuring with a tapered comparator is much easier than with a 90 degree edge at the end of a straight hole. Using this insert with the Hornady LNL OAL tools yielded consistant readings on each test. No need to take multiple readings and find the average. A second reading to verify the first and your done. There is one difference though. Getting a reading is quickly done, but if you apply mild pressure and wait a bit you can watch the number go about .002 lower. It feels like your squeezing the air out from between the bullet and comparator surfaces. A tap on the side of the bullet's base is needed to release it from the insert. Rest assured, the insert left no marks on the bullets I measured. This review covers the 6mm insert used to measure 8 different bullets, 80 to 106 grains, by Berger, Sierra and Lapua.
Nice heavy steel, not aluminum(23.03.2011)
Used with the Sinclair comparator body and a caliper to check OAL (base to ogive or datum point) on the bullet. Easy to use with repeatable results. Get two comparators with inserts and length sort the bearing surface area of bullets to help improve accuracy.
Perhaps Too Much Taper(25.11.2013)
I was using this insert to sort 69 grain Sierra Match King bullets. The ogive on the bullet combined with the taper on the insert makes it hard to get repeatable measurements using a caliper. It's much too easy to cause the bullet to move further down into the insert while taking the measurement. The same thing happens with assembled rounds. For these bullets, the Hornady insert works better.
I have a bullet sorting stand and comparators on order, I hope that is more repeatable.
Also, I use a dial caliper. I can zero out the thousandth's but not the tenths of an inch. It would be nice if the comparator assembled to the insert would measure about 1.01 inches rather than 1.11 inches. It's easier to mentally subtract 1 inch from the measurement than 1.1 inches. If you use a digital caliper, it's not a problem.
Buy Hornady instead(16.01.2014)
Simply does not work. When trying to measure SMK in 52, 69, and 77 gr, the comparator simply slides all the way over the bullet until it reaches the case.
works for me(27.06.2016)
I have three different bullet comparators in 22cal, all three measures the ogive at a different point on the bullet. The Sinclair is the best it repeats, and is made of stainless steel so it will not change in time. If seating the bullets deep it maybe a problem it has the largest hole of the three comparator I have . This comparator works great for me.
Improved design, except for 1 problem.(23.12.2010)
All the details in my rating for the 6mm comparator apply here too, but I've found a problem with the .204. To get optimum groups with my Cooper M21 20 TAC, some of my loads need to be seated very deep. The Sierra 32 gr MK and Hornady 45 gr SP achieve 0.25 MOA or better, when seated 0.100" off the lands. That's right, 1/10" jump! At this depth, this new comparator runs into the mouth of the case before it can come into contact with the bullet, so it's useless. And I'm not seating these bullets past their bearing surfaces. I'd like to see the geometry of this insert changed so that the max diameter of it's tapered hole would be 0.202". Right now I measure it at 0.211". In fact all of these new Sinclair inserts should limit their maximum taper diameters to (at most) the diameter of the bearing surface of bullet they are used for.
you get what u pay for(10.03.2014)
Excellent quality - much better than the competition - made of steel - much better that aluminum. Thanks Sinclair!
Don't buy(02.07.2015)
The hole in the comparator is that large the base of a bullet goes below the face of the comparator.
I had to give it a star rating but in reality it doesn't even qualify for the one star.
Advised to return it but International shipping is going to be more than the cost of the 3 comparator inserts.
NOPE!(09.04.2016)
Hole sizing is incorrect on mine as well. And I'm not seeing an online way for tech support. Product is useless.
Size Issue Not Corrected(20.12.2016)
The size issue that others have written has not been corrected. The hole is just too large, period. I am very surprised that this has not been rectified, especially coming from Sinclair. I was issued a return tag and I've asked for a Hornady comparator insert and a credit for the difference. I also ordered a Sinclair 22, a 6mm, and a 30 cal comparator, all of which work satisfactorily.
Référence: 749011959 SINCLAIR INTERNATIONAL XL BULLET COMPARATOR & BUMP GAGE BODY050806111332 Ce comparateur Sinclair est un excellent outil pour trier les balles par longueur de base. C'est une étape précieuse si tu envisages de couper le méplat de la balle. REMARQUE : Lors du tri d'un grand nombre de balles, un pied à coulisse numérique est parfois un meilleur choix pour certains chargeurs que le pied à coulisse à cadran. Un outil alternatif pour trier les balles est notre support de tri de balles Sinclair (#59-2000) qui utilise ses propres comparateurs uniques. Notre comparateur de balles Sinclair se fixe à la lame de ton pied à coulisse et utilise des inserts pour chaque calibre spécifique. Les inserts sont en acier inoxydable et usinés avec un cône et une courte section droite pour reproduire plus précisément la gorge de la chambre. Cela élimine le balancement rencontré avec de nombreux comparateurs qui ont des trous standard percés. Notre conception te permet de mesurer rapidement et avec précision la surface de contact de la balle. Les inserts de comparateur sont disponibles pour les calibres de 17 à 45, et ils peuvent être utilisés à la fois dans les corps de comparateur Sinclair et les anciens corps de Stoney Point. Ces inserts ne sont pas destinés à mesurer des cartouches chargées à la longueur de magazine ou plus courtes. Pour cette application, merci de consulter nos comparateurs de balles Sinclair (#09-600 et #09-700).
41.9CHF36CHF 41.90
*
Délai de livraison environ 8-15 jours depuis l'entrepôt des États-Unis.
Référence: 749002552 SINCLAIR INTERNATIONAL BULLET COMPARATOR & BUMP GAGE BODY Ref Fabricant: 091000050806111530 Ce comparateur Sinclair est un excellent outil pour trier les balles par longueur de base. C'est une étape précieuse si tu envisages de couper le méplat de la balle. REMARQUE : Lors du tri d'un grand nombre de balles, un pied à coulisse numérique est parfois un meilleur choix pour certains chargeurs que le pied à coulisse à cadran. Un outil alternatif pour trier les balles est notre support de tri de balles Sinclair (#59-2000) qui utilise ses propres comparateurs uniques. Notre comparateur de balles Sinclair se fixe à la lame de ton pied à coulisse et utilise des inserts pour chaque calibre spécifique. Les inserts sont en acier inoxydable et usinés avec un cône et une courte section droite pour reproduire plus précisément la gorge de la chambre. Cela élimine le balancement rencontré avec de nombreux comparateurs qui ont des trous standard percés. Notre conception te permet de mesurer rapidement et avec précision la surface de contact de la balle. Les inserts de comparateur sont disponibles pour les calibres de 17 à 45, et ils peuvent être utilisés à la fois dans les corps de comparateur Sinclair et les anciens corps de Stoney Point. Ces inserts ne sont pas destinés à mesurer des cartouches chargées à la longueur de magazine ou plus courtes. Pour cette application, merci de consulter nos comparateurs de balles Sinclair (#09-600 et #09-700).
29.9CHF28CHF 29.90
*
Délai de livraison environ 8-15 jours depuis l'entrepôt des États-Unis.
This Sinclair Comparator is an excellent tool to use to sort bullets by base to give length. This is a valuable step if you are considering trimming the bullet meplat. NOTE: When sorting a lot of bullets, a digital caliper is sometimes a better choice for some handloaders than a dial caliper. An alternative tool to use for sorting bullets is our Sinclair Bullet Sorting Stand (#59-2000) which uses its own unique comparators. Our Sinclair Bullet Comparator attaches to the blade of your caliper and uses inserts for each specific caliber. The inserts are stainless steel and machined with a taper and a short straight section to more accurately duplicate the chamber throat. This eliminates the wobble experienced with many comparators which have standard drilled holes. Our design allows you to quickly and accurately measure the bullet's bearing surface of the bullet. Comparator inserts are available in 17 thru 45 caliber, and they can be used in both the Sinclair and older Stoney Point comparator bodies. These inserts are not intended to measure rounds seated to magazine length or shorter. For this application please see our Sinclair Bullet Comparators (#09-600 and #09-700).
Plus...
Ce comparateur Sinclair est un excellent outil pour trier les balles par longueur de base. C'est une étape précieuse si tu envisages de couper le méplat de la balle. REMARQUE : Lors du tri d'un grand nombre de balles, un pied à coulisse numérique est parfois un meilleur choix pour certains chargeurs que le pied à coulisse à cadran. Un outil alternatif pour trier les balles est notre support de tri de balles Sinclair (#59-2000) qui utilise ses propres comparateurs uniques. Notre comparateur de balles Sinclair se fixe à la lame de ton pied à coulisse et utilise des inserts pour chaque calibre spécifique. Les inserts sont en acier inoxydable et usinés avec un cône et une courte section droite pour reproduire plus précisément la gorge de la chambre. Cela élimine le balancement rencontré avec de nombreux comparateurs qui ont des trous standard percés. Notre conception te permet de mesurer rapidement et avec précision la surface de contact de la balle. Les inserts de comparateur sont disponibles pour les calibres de 17 à 45, et ils peuvent être utilisés à la fois dans les corps de comparateur Sinclair et les anciens corps de Stoney Point. Ces inserts ne sont pas destinés à mesurer des cartouches chargées à la longueur de magazine ou plus courtes. Pour cette application, merci de consulter nos comparateurs de balles Sinclair (#09-600 et #09-700).
Plus...
Évaluations client de SINCLAIR INTERNATIONAL XL BULLET COMPARATOR & BUMP GAGE BODY
Nombre d'évaluations: 13
De brownells.com: 13
Note moyenne: 3.1
Great little tool(13.12.2013)
I bought this comparator to use with the Sinclair XL Comparator body. It fits like a glove and gives accurate measurements from the ojive of the bullet to the base. Buy two of them and two bodies and you can also measure bearing surface of the bullet. I would definitely buy it again.
Well built, but not accurate(20.01.2015)
I have the Hornady bullet comparator that I normally use. When my shooting partner and I noticed a .010 difference in our Hornady headspace comparator, I ordered the Sinclair bump gauge and the bullet comparator. The Sinclair tool is produced from quality steel and is well constructed.
My issue with the tool is that on Sierra MK and Berger Juggernauts, it slides all the way down almost to the base of the bullet. I can't get repeatable results with this tool, where I can with the Hornady tool which is only made of light aluminum. The Sinclair tool does not seem to be measuring from the ogive, but more from the bullet base. As another user reviewed, when used with Comparator body, it measure 1.1 inches, rather than 1.0 like the Hornady. Because of the inaccuracy and non-repeatable readings on the same bullet, I can't continue using this.
Well built and accurate(18.07.2016)
I reviewed this item back in Jan 2015. However, I had just read that the manufacturer had some quality control issues back then, but these have been corrected, so I decided to give these another try. These new ones are much better than before, and hold the bullet securely at the ogive, or the pressure ring on the base by the boat tail. I ordered 2 to get readings on the bearing surface for different bullets, and I get accurate, repeatable readings every time. I have them in the Sinclair body. Since they are cut with a chambering reamer, the bullet fits securely in the insert. In my Hornady insert, the bullet will "wobble" since the insert is cut straight, and you have to make sure it goes on straight on the caliper. This inserts are made of high quality material, and are a must for competitive long range shooters.
Improved design for comparator inserts.(07.12.2010)
Measuring with a tapered comparator is much easier than with a 90 degree edge at the end of a straight hole. Using this insert with the Hornady LNL OAL tools yielded consistant readings on each test. No need to take multiple readings and find the average. A second reading to verify the first and your done. There is one difference though. Getting a reading is quickly done, but if you apply mild pressure and wait a bit you can watch the number go about .002 lower. It feels like your squeezing the air out from between the bullet and comparator surfaces. A tap on the side of the bullet's base is needed to release it from the insert. Rest assured, the insert left no marks on the bullets I measured. This review covers the 6mm insert used to measure 8 different bullets, 80 to 106 grains, by Berger, Sierra and Lapua.
Nice heavy steel, not aluminum(23.03.2011)
Used with the Sinclair comparator body and a caliper to check OAL (base to ogive or datum point) on the bullet. Easy to use with repeatable results. Get two comparators with inserts and length sort the bearing surface area of bullets to help improve accuracy.
Perhaps Too Much Taper(25.11.2013)
I was using this insert to sort 69 grain Sierra Match King bullets. The ogive on the bullet combined with the taper on the insert makes it hard to get repeatable measurements using a caliper. It's much too easy to cause the bullet to move further down into the insert while taking the measurement. The same thing happens with assembled rounds. For these bullets, the Hornady insert works better.
I have a bullet sorting stand and comparators on order, I hope that is more repeatable.
Also, I use a dial caliper. I can zero out the thousandth's but not the tenths of an inch. It would be nice if the comparator assembled to the insert would measure about 1.01 inches rather than 1.11 inches. It's easier to mentally subtract 1 inch from the measurement than 1.1 inches. If you use a digital caliper, it's not a problem.
Buy Hornady instead(16.01.2014)
Simply does not work. When trying to measure SMK in 52, 69, and 77 gr, the comparator simply slides all the way over the bullet until it reaches the case.
works for me(27.06.2016)
I have three different bullet comparators in 22cal, all three measures the ogive at a different point on the bullet. The Sinclair is the best it repeats, and is made of stainless steel so it will not change in time. If seating the bullets deep it maybe a problem it has the largest hole of the three comparator I have . This comparator works great for me.
Improved design, except for 1 problem.(23.12.2010)
All the details in my rating for the 6mm comparator apply here too, but I've found a problem with the .204. To get optimum groups with my Cooper M21 20 TAC, some of my loads need to be seated very deep. The Sierra 32 gr MK and Hornady 45 gr SP achieve 0.25 MOA or better, when seated 0.100" off the lands. That's right, 1/10" jump! At this depth, this new comparator runs into the mouth of the case before it can come into contact with the bullet, so it's useless. And I'm not seating these bullets past their bearing surfaces. I'd like to see the geometry of this insert changed so that the max diameter of it's tapered hole would be 0.202". Right now I measure it at 0.211". In fact all of these new Sinclair inserts should limit their maximum taper diameters to (at most) the diameter of the bearing surface of bullet they are used for.
you get what u pay for(10.03.2014)
Excellent quality - much better than the competition - made of steel - much better that aluminum. Thanks Sinclair!
Don't buy(02.07.2015)
The hole in the comparator is that large the base of a bullet goes below the face of the comparator.
I had to give it a star rating but in reality it doesn't even qualify for the one star.
Advised to return it but International shipping is going to be more than the cost of the 3 comparator inserts.
NOPE!(09.04.2016)
Hole sizing is incorrect on mine as well. And I'm not seeing an online way for tech support. Product is useless.
Size Issue Not Corrected(20.12.2016)
The size issue that others have written has not been corrected. The hole is just too large, period. I am very surprised that this has not been rectified, especially coming from Sinclair. I was issued a return tag and I've asked for a Hornady comparator insert and a credit for the difference. I also ordered a Sinclair 22, a 6mm, and a 30 cal comparator, all of which work satisfactorily.